Review for 1166 Bay Street Condos – ⭐ 8/10 on RateTheCondo.com
Location: 1166 Bay Street, Toronto
Built: 1980s
Unit Sizes: All over 2,000 sq ft
Maintenance Fees: High ($ +/sq ft)
Amenities: Valet parking, indoor pool, gym, BBQ area
Neighborhood: Yorkville – walking distance to shops, restaurants, and luxury retail
Tucked away in the heart of Yorkville , 1166 Bay Street Condos offers a rare combination of spacious layouts, prime location, and a strong sense of community. While it shows its age in some areas, this building still holds up as a standout option for those seeking a more mature, upscale lifestyle in downtown Toronto.
📍 Location & Lifestyle: 9/10
As one of Toronto’s most prestigious neighborhoods, Yorkville puts you steps from top-tier shopping, fine dining, and cultural attractions. The walkability score is through the roof — everything from high-end boutiques to gourmet markets is just a short stroll away.
🏢 Building & Units: 8/10
What truly distinguishes 1166 Bay is its massive unit sizes — every single one is over 2,000 sq ft , which is practically unheard of in today’s condo market. These are true family-sized units , not the small studios and 1-bedrooms that developers often pack into newer buildings to maximize profits.
Because of the large layouts and higher maintenance fees (a result of older systems and premium services like valet parking ), the building attracts mostly end users — people who live here long-term rather than investors or short-term renters. This creates a stable, tight-knit community where residents tend to stay for many years, take pride in their homes, and know their neighbors — something increasingly rare in the fast-paced world of modern condos.
🧱 Design & Amenities: 7/10
Being built in the 1980s, the design feels a bit dated compared to sleeker, minimalist new builds. Units don’t have floor-to-ceiling windows , and the amenities, while functional, aren’t flashy by today’s standards. The indoor pool , gym , and BBQ terrace are well-maintained but show signs of age. That said, they serve their purpose and are used regularly by residents who appreciate practicality over trendiness.
💰 Costs & Demographics: 8/10
With above-average maintenance fees , this isn’t a budget-friendly option. However, these costs reflect the luxury services offered — especially valet parking, which is rare even in newer buildings. Most residents are either mortgage-free or financially secure individuals who value space, privacy, and stability.
Final Thoughts: 8/10
1166 Bay Street may not have the polish of newer developments, but it makes up for it with timeless elegance , generous layouts , and a strong community vibe . It's ideal for downsizers, professionals, and families looking for a quiet, upscale home in one of Toronto’s best locations.
📍 Best suited for: Long-term residents, families, and those who prefer a stable, respectful community over high turnover and investor-heavy buildings.
